Couldn't War Be a Noble Quest?
by Wes Penre, May 21, 2006
Last Updated:
Sunday, June 04, 2006 12:18:04 PM |
n
occasion, I receive e-mails from visitors who claim that the Iraq
war is justified, and if the U.S. attacks Iran, that would be
justified as well. How come? Because, according to those people, the
Iraqi and Iranian regimes are extremely threatening to world peace
and some people tell me that the best thing to do is to wipe those
countries out from the world map all together.
Other people say that some wars can be justified due to protecting
religious beliefs.
Obviously, those persons talk out of fear. They are terrified that
they and their families and
friends will be the next targets of terrorism and violent death. This
is quite understandable, until you can see the whole picture.
But...could those people be right? Couldn't war sometimes be a noble quest?
Years ago, I read a book called "The
Gods of Eden", by William Bramley (Avon Books
©1989).
He had the following viewpoints on war and violence, and why war is
not a noble or a good thing. I strongly agree with what he is
saying, with one addition. I will come to that after the quote. Here
is William Bramley:
"What is war, then, if not a noble quest?
Analyzed down to its most basic components,
warfare is nothing more than the act of causing solid objects to destructively
collide with other solid objects. That might sometimes be fun, but there is not
much spiritual benefit to be derives from constantly engaging in it. Although it
is true that war has many elements of a game, the destructive nature of war
causes it to be little more than a series of criminal acts: primarily arson,
battery, and murder. This reveals something of great significance:
War is the institutionalization of
criminality. War can never bring about spiritual improvement because
criminality is one of the main causes of mental and spiritual deterioration.
Societies which exalt criminal actions as a
noble quest will suffer a rapid deterioration in the mental and spiritual
condition of their inhabitants. 'Spiritual' doctrines which exalt combat are
doctrines which degrade the human race.
Is not warfare in pursuit of a just cause a
good thing?
The biggest problem with using violent force
to fight for a cause is that the rules of force operate on competely [sic]
different principles than do the principles of right and wrong. The victorious
use of violent force depends upon skills that have nothing to do with whether or
not one's cause is a just one. The man who can draw his six-shooter the fastest
is not necessarily the man with the best ideals. We like our heroes when they
can outshoot or physically overpower the bad guys, and there is nothing wrong
with their being able to do so, but not all of our heroes can. Those who have a
legitimate cause should therefore be wary of the temptation to assert the
rightness of their beliefs in the arena of violent force since their cause may
undeservedly lose. There are many effective methods to promote good causes and
make them win, but those methods are seldom used in a world educated to use
violence as the ultimate court of appeal[1].
|
In addition to this, I think killing another human being can
never be justified, except under one condition - self defense.
Someone may say that this is a contradiction, because there are
always people who kill in self defense when there is a war going on.
This is true, and I am not saying that a nation who is attacked
should just have their citizens stand there and be slaughtered,
but what I mean is that war as a concept is not a solution to
anything. Even if the "good side" wins, the blood this nation or
group has on their hands will degrade them and set them
back when it comes to their spiritual growth. Wars and violent
conflicts are major reasons why we still are spiritually ignorant.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Footnote:
[1]
Bramley: "The Gods of Eden" p. 166-167.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
- - - - - - - -
Disclaimer
- - - - - - - -
|