Israel - A State Built On Lies
by Punyapriya Dasgupta
Last Updated:
Sunday, August 20, 2006 09:16:20 AM |
he outcome of Israeli military's own inquiry into Qana II was to Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International
something far from the truth. HRW said that the massacre of at least
28 Lebanese – mostly children and women -- on July 30 was the
"latest product" of Israel's indiscriminating bombing. Amnesty added
that Israel had a history of either not investigating civilian
deaths or conducting flawed inquiries. It was the same excuse this
time as the one Israel offered for the horrific killing of 106
Lebanese refugees and four UN soldiers by artillery fire on a UNIFIL
compound at the same village of Qana in Lebanon ten years ago. On
both occasions, Israel did not know there were civilians at the
targeted points. So pretended Israel's leaders. And they claimed
that they were aiming only at Hezbollah each time. Where was
Hezbollah? Among so many dead there was not one Hezbollah body nor
any relic of its equipment either in 1996 or in 2006.
Israel has a history not only of trying to cover up its massacres of
harmless civilians but of downright lying to camouflage every one of
its dark designs. It goes back to the beginning of political Zionism
and its "spiritual father", Theodore Herzl (1860-1904),
Hungarian-born journalist, who was fascinated by the French proverb:
Qui veut la fin, veut les moyens (he who desires the end, desires
the means). In an explanation of what made him start thinking of a
Jewish State in Palestine he came out with a doctored view of his
own hindsight. He wrote in an essay in defence of his Zionism that
during the trial and public humiliation of Dreyfus in France, he had
heard crowds shout "Death to the Jews". Herzl had reported the
notorious trial of Alfred Dreyfus, a Jewish captain in the French
army, for a Vienna newspaper, a few years earlier. His news
dispatches said that the crowds had roared: "Death to the Traitor."
Herzl gave away his own game later when he admitted that the Jews in
France saw themselves as almost within the social mainstream. Faced
with charges from the French Jews that his Zionism was hindering
their total assimilation in the French nation, he turned sarcastic
and wrote: "If any or all of French Jewry protest against this
scheme [of a Jewish State], because they are already 'assimilated',
my answer is simple. They are Israelite Frenchmen? Splendid. This is
a private affair for Jews alone."
Herzl spent his final years waiting at the gates of European
monarchs and Turkey's Sultan, begging for any kind of a signal for
him to carry Occidental civilization to Palestine by turning "this
plague-ridden, blighted corner of the Orient" into a Jewish State.
He spoke also of "spiriting the penniless Palestinians away" from
Palestine. But when an Arab notable in Jerusalem asked him if he was
really contemplating driving the Palestinians out of their homes,
Herzl wrote: " Who would think of sending them away? It is their
well being, their individual wealth which we will increase by
bringing in our own."
The forked tongue is a constant in the history of Zionism. Over long
years the Zionists worked single-mindedly for a take-over of
Palestine but kept on denying that aim until they had achieved it.
Who exactly coined the crisp slogan of a "land [Palestine] without
people to a people [Jews] without land" is not known. The credit is
given sometimes to Herzl himself and sometimes to his English
collaborator, Israel Zangwill. Max Nordeau, another Hungarian-born
associate of Herzl , had a twinge of conscience when he learnt that
Palestine was not a land without people. He said: "I did not know
that – but then we are committing an injustice!" But he quickly
recovered and claimed that the word "homeland", used in the Balfour
Declaration and the League of Nations Mandate to camouflage the
contemplated State for the Jews in Palestine was his idea. The
infamous Balfour Declaration (1917) was the first tall feather in
the cap of Chaim Weizmann, an arrogant Jewish biochemist who dined
with British prime ministers and helped British war efforts in
1914-18. In fact, his was the first draft of the document by which
one country pledged to give away another to some people scattered
over the world. Albert Einstein, who opposed the idea of a Jewish
State and later refused to become Israel's first President, asked
Weizmann: "What about the Arabs if Palestine were to be given to the
Jews?" Weizmann replied: "What Arabs? They are hardly of any
consequence." To Emir Feisal, son of Sherif Hussein of Mecca, whom
Lawrence of Arabia had courted for help against Turkey during World
War I, Weizmann said: "The Jews do not propose to set up a Jewish
government." Even as late as in 1930, the cunning Weizmann thought
it politic to keep his scheme under wraps: He said: "If a Jewish
State were possible, I would be strongly for it. I am not for it
because I consider it unrealizable." When near the goal, thanks
largely to Jewish terrorism, Weizmann made a show of his anguish at
UN and in his own words, hung his head in shame because the Jews had
violated the commandment: Thou shall not kill. That, of course, did
not prevent Weizmann from feeling "proud of our boys" when they blew
up Hotel King David, administrative headquarters of Britain's
Palestine Mandate in Jerusalem, killing 92 and injuring 58 Britons,
Arabs and Jews. When the Jewish State was realized Weizmann became
its first President.
Israel is the only State admitted to UN membership on condition that
it would be obedient to the world body and be bound, more
specifically, by two General Assembly resolutions – of November 1947
for partition of Palestine and of December 1948 enshrining the right
of the Palestinian refugees to return to their homes or be satisfied
with compensation. A document on UN record, dated 29 November 1948,
reads: "On behalf of the State of Israel, I, Moshe Shertok, Minister
for Foreign Affairs, being duly authorised by the State Council of
Israel, declare that the State of Israel hereby unreservedly accepts
the obligation of the UN Charter and undertakes to honour them from
the day when it becomes a Member of the United Nations." Four days
after Israel had been accepted by UN as one of its members, David
Ben Gurion, Israel's first prime minister, declared in the Knesset
that UN's Palestine partition resolution no longer held any moral
force
|