Wiggins law on treating inmates
awaits Arnold
By DAVID RYAN Register Staff
Writer
Thursday, September 27,
2007
A bill
before Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger could lighten the load
for Napa County Jail when it comes to dealing with
mentally ill inmates — but observers say even the need
for a measure to allow jailers to forcibly medicate
inmates shows the state mental health system is in
crisis.
SB 568, authored by state Sen. Patricia
Wiggins, D-Santa Rosa, makes it legal for staff at
county jails to make prescription medication available
for inmates found incompetent to stand trial. A doctor
could prescribe medication for the inmate and jail staff
would be in charge of making it available for
them.
The
measure is designed to solve temporary problems at jails
as they wait for the opportunity to transfer inmates to
facilities such as Napa State Hospital. Napa State,
which has special programs for those found incompetent
to stand trial, including individualized medication and
mock court training.
Administrators at some
jails, including in Sonoma County, have complained that
they have limited capabilities to deal with unstable
inmates and yet are sometimes told there is no room for
the inmates at Napa State.
find often that they
must wait before they can transfer them.
“The
reality is, more and more mentally ill are being housed
in jails, which by definition are not treatment
facilities,” Wiggins said in a prepared statement. “This
bill serves as an interim measure and the county jails
have assured me they have no intention of becoming
mental hospitals.”
Public defenders throughout
Northern California have long been frustrated by a
waiting list at Napa State Hospital for clients that
need to undergo treatment before they are ready to stand
trial as competent adults.
Waits can sometimes be
a matter of months, even the U.S. Court of Appeals for
the Ninth Circuit, which interprets federal law for
western states including California, said in a 2003
case, Oregon Advocacy Center v. Mink, that waits
shouldn’t be longer than seven days.
“As someone
who works for the government, I’m sorry the resources
are so taxed,” said Barry Melton, Yolo County public
defender and SB 568 representative for the California
Public Defender’s Association. “However, the law is the
law and California has to follow the law, particularly
when it comes to federal constitutional
standards.”
The U.S. Constitution bans holding
inmates indefinitely without a speedy trial. Public
defenders have in some cases invoked the Due Process
Clause to force their clients to the front of waiting
lists to get into the state mental health
system.
Despite Melton’s assertion, he backed off
opposing the bill because proponents included a
requirement that a doctor determine whether a person can
be properly medicated in jail.
“Just because you
supply somebody medication doesn’t mean you’re treating
them,” Melton said, pointing out the benefits of mock
trial training at Napa State Hospital. “I don’t think
it’s the kind of long term fix that’s going to work.
Yes, we withdrew our opposition ... but we never
supported the bill.”
Melton said the state mental
health system is in danger of suffering the same fate as
the state prison system, which has fallen under federal
court dictates to try and solve overcrowding
issues.
Wiggins said she never intended for the
bill to solve overcrowding issues in the state mental
hospital system.
“The Oregon case raises some
critical issues, but we can’t wait for, or speculate
about, the outcome” on further appeal, she said in a
statement. “Delays in treatment for defendants who are
seriously mentally ill can pose problems not only for
the defendants, but for people around them as well. My
bill seeks to narrow the gap between diagnosis and
treatment.”
Schwarzenegger has until midnight,
Oct. 12 to sign or veto the bill before it automatically
becomes law without his signature. His staff has not
indicated what he will do.
Print this story
| Email this
story | Browse today's articles in this
category: Previous
| Next
1 comment(s)
Tax Payer wrote on
Sep 27, 2007 9:21 AM:
" If Wiggins is pushing
this there is sure to be a union getting the benefits.
"
Log
in to join the conversation
Comment
guidelines
All
comments will be screened and may take several hours to
be posted.
•
Keep comments clear, concise and focused on the topic in
the story.
•
Comments exceeding 300 words will not be posted.
•
Refrain from personal attacks, degrading comments or
remarks that do not add to a constructive
dialogue.
•
Comments implying suspects in crime-related stories are
guilty before they have been proven so in a court of law
will be deleted.
•
Do not post e-mail addresses or links except for pages
on Napavalleyregister.com or government Web sites.
•
Comments will not be edited - they will be approved or
declined.
•
Comments may be used in the print edition of the
newspaper.
•
If you feel a posted comment has violated our
guidelines, please contact dross@napanews.com or
bkennedy@napanews.com
For
further information on the comment guidelines, click
here.
|